It is always exciting to shop for a mattress. Nowadays most people shop for a new car more often than a new mattress, which only makes mattress shopping so much more fun. Lucky indeed are the ones with a new baby. They get to have all the fun shopping for a toddler mattress.
Before you make the decision, we know you’d want to hear other people’s opinions on the best toddler mattress. You have come to the right place for that. You will find in this article real experience and original thoughts, on top of the usual conventional wisdom about toddler mattresses.
A prominent conventional wisdom is that a toddler mattress must be firm. This is to prevent the little one from sinking into the mattress which can cause suffocation, one of the causes of sudden infant death syndrome. It doesn’t mean that the mattress has to be super-duper firm. A toddler weighs a fraction of an adult, so a firm mattress for a toddler is just no squishiness or pillow-top.
The toddler mattress is also known as a crib mattress. As is the case with toddler pillows, the size of toddler mattresses has been standardized so we don’t have to worry about getting a queen or twin mattress. Just like regular mattresses, there are basically two types of toddler mattresses: foam and innerspring.
There are more parts in innerspring mattresses so they are generally more expensive, though the best foam mattresses can be just as costly. The best foam mattresses would use the densest foam layers so they are heavier than cheap foam mattresses, but usually nowhere near as heavy as good innerspring mattresses (unless Tempur-Pedic decided to make a toddler mattress).
All toddler mattresses for sale in the US must meet safety standards in terms of flammability and harmful emissions. We should also demand comfort, durability, reliable waterproof cover, and ease of cleaning.
Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress
Sealy Soybean Form-Core is a foam toddler mattress. The thick foam core uses natural and renewable soybeans to add firmness to a level that’s perfect for infants and toddlers. It employs a thin layer of cotton-based cushion over and below the foam core for comfort. All of this is wrapped in an embossed waterproof vinyl cover.
This mattress is comfortable and safe for babies and toddlers. The foam is CertiPur-US certified made without harmful chemicals. The cushion layer is made with non-allergenic cotton. The waterproof cover features lock-stitched binding to prevent seepage. The vinyl material is stain-resistant and will not attract dust and other allergens.
The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core toddler mattress is made in the USA and comes with a lifetime warranty! Lifetime for a family with one child means about 5 years since this mattress is rated to hold up to 60 pounds. However, keep it in good shape and one could conceivably reuse it for future newborns.
This foam toddler mattress weighs only 8.3 pounds (5” thick). It is very easy to flip and move around.
Transitions Baby and Toddler Mattress
The Transitions mattress by Safety 1st is so named because this foam crib mattress features two levels of firmness on each side. One side is tuned for the weight of an infant and the other side for a toddler. This mattress is rated to hold a child weighing up to 100 pounds!
The two firmness levels are achieved by an additional layer of cushion on the toddler side. Compared to an infant, it is safe and more comfortable for a toddler to sink slightly into the bed. This is all wrapped in a water-resistant PVC-free cover.
The foam is CentiPur-US certified for being made without harmful chemicals. In addition, this mattress is GREENGUARD Gold certified for low chemical emissions which would ensure good air quality around the toddler.
The Safety 1st Transitions crib mattress is comfortable and just firm enough for safety. It is 5.5” thick and weighs only 8 pounds. The manufacturer warranty period is 24 months. For a toddler mattress, it makes little difference whether the warranty is 24 months or 24 years. The kid won’t remain a toddler for too long.
Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress
The Serta Tranquility Eco is our favorite innerspring toddler mattress. The two sides feature different firmness, with an extra blended cotton layer on the toddler side for comfort.
The innerspring comprises 120 heavy-duty coils with full-perimeter border wires. You can trust Sealy to know everything there is to know about innerspring mattresses and this toddler mattress was designed as meticulously as their adult mattresses. The outer cover is smooth waterproof vinyl.
This toddler mattress has all relevant safety certifications and more. The foams are CertiPUR-US certified. The entire mattress is GREENGUARD Gold certified for low emissions and good indoor air quality.
The Serta Tranquility Eco is firm and comfortable at the same time. It is very well-built. You don’t exactly feel the innerspring – it’s just there for long-term firmness and durability. We are mightily impressed with this mattress, and we are not alone. This mattress is rated 5 stars in 92% of Amazon buyer reviews, and the other 8%? 4 stars!
This mattress weighs 16 pounds, not too heavy for an innerspring mattress. It is 6 inches thick.
Our pick for the best toddler mattress is the Serta Tranquility Eco. It is designed for both infants and toddlers (firm infant side for infants and softer toddler side for toddlers). We like this mattress just as much for infants. It is safe, easy to clean, and indestructible built.
If you prefer a softer mattress for your child, consider the Safety 1st Transitions. This foam mattress has an additional layer of cushion for the toddler side. It’s an awesome deal at the current selling price.
Go for the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core if you desire the ultimate durability. This award-winning toddler mattress comes with a lifetime manufacturer’s warranty.